Home          Reviews          Columns          Photos          Lists          Feedback          About          Contact

Entertaining Movie Reviews & Discussion

Opinionated Columns & Top 10 Lists

Hi-Resolution Movie Posters & Stills


Oscar Got it Right...

February 23rd, 2008

A response to some of the ridiculous blabbering going on in the wake of the Oscar nominations.

I just read a snippet from a Chicago Tribune column that sent me right over the edge.  I just can't take it anymore.  The article suggested that The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences (AMPAS) shot itself in the foot by nominating so many obscure movies, thereby guaranteeing a poorly rated Oscar ceremony.

First of all, who cares about ratings?  Maybe ABC, who broadcasts the show.  But they don't get a vote.  The voters are made up of all sorts of previous nominees and winners and the members of AMPAS, none of whom have much interest in the difference between 150 million worldwide viewers or 180 million worldwide viewers.

Mediaweek reported: "The problem with the films this year is none of them are huge, mass-appeal hits."  What the hell?  Is that a bad thing?  Quite the opposite.  That is a fantastic thing.  Most of the huge, mass-appeal hits released in a year are horrendous movies.  The general public typically rewards the most publicized films of the year... not necessarily the best.  What is more important -- box office or quality?  It's an easy answer.  No more box office evidence please... it has no bearing.

Entertainment writer (nice title) Marc Caro wrote: "(AMPAS) risks confirming the suspicions of those who think it has grown out of touch with mainstream tastes."  To which I respond: "Thank fuck for that!"

You want an award show that champions the box office winners and the general public's easily won affection? Then, by all means, watch the two shows that already do -- The MTV Movie Awards and The People's Choice Awards.

Of course, this all stems from the fact that the Academy virtually ignored "The Dark Knight" in all the major categories this year.  This, of course, caused mass hysteria in the online fanboy community -- a group that apparently wasn't satisfied with the bone the Academy threw at them in 2003, when they quaintly allowed "Lord of the Rings 3" to win the big one... if only to shut the fat kids up for a while.

Let's get this all straightened out.  Not enough voters thought that a movie about a man in a bat suit with a ridiculously gruff voice should be included in the most prestigious awards show of them all -- and that is some sort of a shock?!?!?  I think not.  Let "Dark Knight" win all the MTV awards it wants.  Let it reign supreme at The People's Choice.  But let's not presume that it carries the emotional heft or skillful writing to be considered a masterpiece.

It is merely a very good example of comic book fluff.  End of story.  Move on with your lives.  The Oscars is the adults turn to play.  Maybe we will throw the fanboys a bone the next time Lord of the Rings gets remade.

***

As a footnote to this column, I want to point out a phrase I read about Heath Ledger's death.  I believe it was on Yahoo news.  The phrase was "an accidental prescription drug encounter" in reference to his passing.

That is a disgusting representation of his death.  He had been a drug addict for a long time and he overdosed by snorting pain medication through a $10 bill.  Let's not glamorize a man, who had an infant child, that was jacked up on pills and had previously been recorded snorting cocaine at a party.  Most people couldn't name three good films he has been in... including "Dark Knight".  The guy wasn't a legend in the making.  He wasn't the next De Niro.

Ledger is merely the figure upon which fanboys have decided to practice their infantile grief and respect.

Ledger was decent in TDK.  Certainly not deserving of all this praise.  He was known for shunning media attention and gushing praise -- and, in his grave, he cannot seem to escape it.

Way to go fanboys! -- He would have been so happy.

© Written by TC Candler

 

Email Me About This Column

 

 

"A website dedicated to film aficionados, hopeless romantics, admirers of artistic beauty & the intellectually curious." -- TC Candler

La Baigneuse
Christian Coigny

Eiffel Tower Girl
Anonymous

Drowse
J Borodina (Eliara)

Pensativa
Vicente Romero

Le Baiser
Robert Doisneau

 


TCCandler.com   ©   All Rights Reserved
Links     -     Privacy     -     Terms of Use     -     Legalities     -     Contact