Home          Reviews          Columns          Photos          Lists          Feedback          About          Contact

The Brothers

The Lovers

The Guns


Defiance

2008

Freedom begins with an act of "Defiance"...

There is a twinge of disappointment writing this review.  "Defiance" is thinner and less rousing than I had hoped.  The trailers made me feel like I was in for an emotional and exciting movie about courage in the face of ultimate evil.  Instead, all I got was a run of the mill TV-movie.

That being said, it is a solid TV-movie.

Daniel Craig and Liev Schreiber star as two brothers who take to the vast Belarussian forests to evade the Nazis.  Once there, their numbers increase rapidly as Jewish families flee with them.  Soon, there are dozens, maybe hundreds of mouths to feed and shelter.  It becomes an almost impossible task in the dead of winter.  It becomes deadly once the Nazis close in on their location.

The action is kept at an arm's length.  We never feel the cold.  We never feel the starvation.  We never feel the danger of bullets flying past our heads.  "Defiance" never seems to engage beyond the surface of things.  At times, it feels like an episode of "Survivor" without the challenges.

I am trivializing somewhat.  This is, after all, a true story of tremendous courage.  It is just that Ed Zwick fails to direct the film in ways that would help us connect.

I was uninvolved.

The performances are all fine.  No need to dust off the mantle for gold statues, but still worthy of note.

"Defiance" will please many but thrill very few.  It is a good movie without ever even attempting to be a great one.  Rent it once it arrives on DVD.  It doesn't merit anything more.

 

© Written by TC Candler

 

Email Me About This Review

Director

Ed Zwick

Cast

Daniel Craig
Liev Schreiber
Alexa Davalos

Running Time

135m

Rated

PG13

 

"A website dedicated to film aficionados, hopeless romantics, admirers of artistic beauty & the intellectually curious." -- TC Candler

La Baigneuse
Christian Coigny

Eiffel Tower Girl
Anonymous

Drowse
J Borodina (Eliara)

Pensativa
Vicente Romero

Le Baiser
Robert Doisneau

 


TCCandler.com   ©   All Rights Reserved
Links     -     Privacy     -     Terms of Use     -     Legalities     -     Contact